Arts Spotlight 1: Medical Autonomy in Art

Authors

  • Hana Mian

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.36399/Surgo.4.913

Abstract

'The Handmaid’s Tale’ is less of a dystopian cautionary tale, and more of a haunting reflection of reality. Writing in Alabama and West Berlin in the early 1980s, Atwood creates the nation of Gilead, a totalitarian state where women are second-class citizens, run by a religious military group. The novel follows ‘Offred', one of the women known as ‘handmaids’ who are forced by the state into reproductive slavery in the face of declining birth rates.

 

The novel's persistent popularity - spiking with political shifts like Trump's candidacies - proves its universal relevance. It is banned from many public schools in the US, which is ironic given that in the book, reading is illegal for women. 40 years since its publishing, Gilead's authoritarian regime of control over women's bodies still holds up a mirror to today's attacks on reproductive and gender-affirming healthcare in the UK and beyond. Forced Sterilisation, LGBTQ+ 'conversion therapy', female genital mutilation, and restricted reproductive healthcare access are key themes in the novel. These are of course not the inventions of sci-fi, but realities in many different settings across the world, especially for lower-income communities and people of colour. Atwood herself stated, 'I would not put anything into it that human societies have not already done'. The novel’s setting, a world of environmental collapse and declining birth rates, also feels uncomfortably close to our own. Reproductive health is already seeing the effects of heatwaves, pollution, and food and water insecurity.¹

 

Gilead's government utilises medicine as a method of control, enforced by physicians. The doctors depicted in the novel are unnerving' they conduct exams on the handmaids from behind a curtain, barred from seeing their faces. Offred describes herself as a 'two-legged womb', a brutal way to illustrate how women are viewed in this society. The way medicine is practiced in the novel feels sinister - it's a reversion to paternalism but now with access to modern equipment and knowledge, making it all the more frightening to readers today. The novel is a reminder to us as future doctors of our very real responsibility to advocate for and protect the autonomy of our patients in a rapidly changing world. 

 

‘Just Take Ibuprofen’, Emily Kampa

This copper plate print depicts the instruments used in an intrauterine device (IUD) insertion, to scale. In person, the print is displayed horizontally on a medical cart, allowing viewers to see it in a similar way as the artist would have for the first time. I like this piece because it’s a good visual reminder of how intimidating procedures that we see all the time can seem from a patient's perspective. Not everyone experiences significant  pain during/after this procedure - however, clinicians generally underestimate the pain and anxiety experienced.2 Guidance states that there is no single 'best' pain intervention, but that forms of local anaesthesia have better outcomes.3 Notably, studies of prophylactic ibuprofen use have not shown a reduction in pain3 - but the NHS website still recommends it!4 It also provides limited information about what pain management options are available, but simultaneously advises those who are concerned about pain the raise this themselves with the practitioner. This advice places responsibility on the patient rather than the clinician, which could affect the consistency of care. If a patient is unaware that alternative interventions can be used, how can they know to ask?

 

Additionally, anticipated pain and anxiety can produce higher pain scores during this procedure.5,6 A reassuring, supportive practitioner who works with the user will not only reduce pain at the current appointment, but also lay the groundwork for better outcomes at future appointments - this applies to all gynaecological procedures! 

 

1. Segal TR, Giudice LC. Systematic review of climate change effects on reproductive health. Fertility and Sterility. 2022;118(2):215-223. doi:10.1016/j.fertnstert.2022.06.005

2. Akintomide H, Brima N, Sewell RD, Stephenson JM. Patients’ experiences and providers’ observations on pain during intrauterine device insertion. The European Journal of Contraception & Reproductive Health Care 2015;20(4):319-26

3.The Faculty of Sexual and Reproductive Healthcare of the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists. FSRH Statement: Pain Associated with Insertion of Intrauterine Contraception. 2021. https://www.cosrh.org/Common/Uploaded%20files/documents/fsrh-clinical-statement-pain-associated-with-insertion-of-iut-jul-2021.pdf

4. NHS. Getting an IUD (intrauterine device) or copper coil fitted or removed. nhs.uk. 29 February 2024. Accessed 28 September 2026. https://www.nhs.uk/contraception/methods-of-contraception/iud-coil/getting-it-fitted-or-emoved/

5. Akdemir Y, Karadeniz M. The relationship between pain at IUD insertion and negative perceptions, anxiety and previous mode of delivery. The European Journal of Health Care 2019;24(3):240-5.Contraception & Reproductive

6. Dina B, Peipert LJ, Zhao Q, Peipert JF. Anticipated pain as a predictor of discomfort with intrauterine device placement. American journal of obstetrics and gynecology 2018;218(2):236-e1.

Published

2026-10-14