Beyond the Diagnosis: Exploring Medical Humanities
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.36399/Surgo.4.907Abstract
What is Universitas 21 (U21) and the Sustainable Development Goals Workshop?
U21 is a global network of research intensive universities that promote international collaboration, education and knowledge exchange. Through this network, students and academics from different professional backgrounds have the opportunity to learn from one another and engage with shared global challenges. As part of this initiative, Lund University in Sweden hosted the U21 sustainable development goals (SDG) workshop, bringing students from different health disciplines together from across the network for a 2 day programme exploring sustainability in health with a specific lens on “humanities in medicine”
Day one: Exploring Humanities in medicine
The first day of the workshop consisted of three lectures from different perspectives: Neuroscience of Empathy and Compassion by Martin Garwicz, Narratives in Medicine by Katarina Bernhardsson, Existential and Ethical Perspectives by Johanna Gustafsson Lundberg. Each lecture approached medical humanities from a different perspective, encouraging us to think beyond the biological understanding of disease and consider how illness is experienced, communicated and understood by both patients and healthcare professionals.
Neuroscience of Empathy and Compassion
This session was delivered by Martin Garwicz, during med school we are always taught to be empathetic whenever a patient comes in with a medical problem. One of the key learning outcomes I learnt from this was understanding the meaning of empathy. It is not a single concept but subdivided into 3 categories: empathetic distress, compassion and perspective taking. Empathetic distress is whenever someone is distressed you also emulate the same distress in the form of stress burnout or even withdrawal from difficult situations. Compassion is the ability to recognise that someone is suffering and wanting to help them without taking on their distress on yourself. Lastly, perspective taking is being able to understand the situation that the patient is in by putting yourself into their shoes or viewpoint, rather than solely through a clinical lens (1).
One of concepts I was fascinated about was understanding the neurobiology behind this, being able to distinguish between empathetic distress and compassionate engagement can allow clinicians to respond effectively to suffering without necessarily internalising the patient's emotional state (1).
Narratives in Medicine by Katarina Bernhardsson
Narrative medicine focuses on how patients communicate and make sense of their experience of illness. To illustrate the power of narrative, Bernhardsson used a famous 6-word story:” For sale: baby shoes, never worn”. Only 6 words were used, however they invite the reader to construct their own narrative around them. The fact that the shoes were unworn was never explained, yet the absence of information encourages us to imagine what may have happened and attach our own meaning to the story. This shows how narratives can communicate far more than the information directly conveyed (2).
For example, when a patient presents to a clinician, their story is often interpreted through questioning, history taking and clinical examination. The clinician often constructs their own narrative in order to explain the patient's illness, which informs the diagnosis and management. In doing so, a patient's description of a symptom may have more than just clinical significance alone; underlying fear, uncertainty, loss or concerns about their future. Transforming a patient's account into a clinical narrative aspects of their original story may therefore be overlooked. A patient's understanding of their illness can be chased by experiences, relationships and beliefs, meaning that the two patients with the same diagnosis may contract different narratives around their illness. A good clinician needs to be able to look beyond constructing a narrative based solely on clinical signs and symptoms, listen attentively, and take a comprehensive approach to understanding the patient's individual experience of illness (2).
Existential and Ethical Perspectives, Johanna Gustafsson Lundberg
This lecture explored how healthcare can be understood not only by clinical outcomes but also individuals' wider experiences. Lundberg's work on existential sustainability seeks to expand conventional understanding of sustainability by considering questions around what constitutes a good life. One concept that interested me was the idea of “docile body” and its relationship with individual responsibility. Modern society is increasingly encouraging people to improve themselves, set goals and take responsibility for their own health and wellbeing. While this can be empowering, it can also set an expectation that individuals should be able to overcome their difficulties through personal change. This made me reflect on how easily responsibility for health can be placed on the individual, despite the fact that people’s opportunities to improve their health are strongly influenced by the circumstances in which they live (3).
For example, Lundberg's work demonstrated how existential perspective can be applied to medical treatment. This involved patients with burnout related symptoms and severe eating disorders engaging with horses, nature and social interaction. While researchers explored how they experienced these activities, this approach considers what treatment means towards the individual and how it can affect their wellbeing. I found this particularly relevant to Medical Humanities because it brought together themes from all three lectures. Garwicz’s discussion of empathy and compassion highlighted how clinicians respond to patients, while Bernhardsson’s exploration of Narrative Medicine emphasised the importance of understanding their individual stories. Lundberg’s existential perspective extended this further by considering how patients’ values, circumstances and sense of wellbeing shape their experience of illness and recovery (4).
Day 2: Applying Medical Humanities to Global Health challenges
The main component of the workshop centred on exploring the relationship between Medical Humanities and Sustainable development Goals (SDGs). We worked in an internationally diverse small group of students from different healthcare disciplines including medicine, nursing and physiotherapy. I found this particularly valuable as it closely simulated a multidisciplinary team (MDT), allowing us to approach the same health challenge from different perspectives and broaden our understanding of complex healthcare problems and highlight perspectives that otherwise be overlooked at.
Case Example: Sexual Health and Education
Case 1 followed Lily Wong, an eighteen-year-old woman from rural Sichuan Province whose family's land was sold for urban development, collapsing her father's farming income. Like many young people from her village, Lily migrated to the city for work. The long hours and poor pay as a waitress led her to be drawn into commercial sex work by her employer. The case does not open with a diagnosis but a chain of economic displacement, migration, and precarious labour, situating Lily's eventual HIV diagnosis within a much wider social fabric before even a single clinical symptom appears. This is why the case was read through the Sustainable Developmental Goals.
Her family's loss of land and livelihood implicates SDG 1 (No Poverty) and SDG 11 (Sustainable Cities and Communities). This is because urbanisation without adequate planning displaced a rural family, making Lily vulnerable to exploitation in the first place. Her entry into sex work, which is a criminalised activity in China for both buyer and seller, sits at the intersection of SDG 5 (Gender Equality) and SDG 8 (Decent Work and Economic Growth), highlighting how the absence of safe employment options for young rural women can translate directly into health risk. Once Lily's fever, oral candidiasis, and eventual HIV diagnosis enter the narrative, SDG 3 (Good Health and Well-being) and SDG 4 (Quality Education) come into play.
We applied a medical humanities framing to the case’s later staging. A year after diagnosis, Lily leaves sex work to become a safe-sex counsellor and returns to her village to educate other young people, only to meet parental resistance, stigma, and community suspicion of "modern" sex education. This arc reframes her from patient to health educator. We highlighted the ethical dilemmas clinicians face around disclosure and reporting obligations for HIV-positive patients, the risk of healthcare workers' own prejudice shaping the quality of care, and the fine but consequential difference between empathy - feeling with a patient - andcompassion, which requires acting on that feeling despite discomfort or social taboo.
Narrative medicine offered the groups an organising method for holding these tensions together. We did not want Lily’s story to be background to a virology lecture on HIV transmission and CD4+ T-cell depletion. Instead, we used her story as the vehicle through which the clinical content was taught — a structure that mirrors narrative medicine's central claim that a patient's account of their life is not incidental to treatment but constitutive of it. By the time Lily is training others to talk about condoms and contraception in a village that associates such conversations with promoting rather than preventing risk, we see that sustainable progress on health (SDG 3) is inseparable from progress on poverty, gender equality, decent work, and education. Clinicians who ignore that interdependence will fail to understand the patients in front of them.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the U21 2026 SDG Workshop demonstrated that medical humanities is a necessary lens for understanding illness in its full social and existential context. Garwicz's dissection of empathy into distress, compassion, and perspective-taking gave us a vocabulary for something clinicians are told to "have" but rarely taught to understand. Bernhardsson's narrative medicine showed how much meaning is lost when a patient's story is flattened into a clinical history. Lundberg's existential perspective reminded us that responsibility for health cannot be placed solely on the individual when their circumstances so often determinetheir options. Taken together, these three lectures built a framework we then had to put into practice.
Lily Wong's case made that framework into something we applied into practice. We could not reduce her story to a diagnosis of HIV. Working through the case in a multidisciplinary group, alongside peers in nursing and other healthcare professions helped reinforce this.
More broadly, this workshop mattered because it taught us to treat the whole person, rather than the disease, and to understand how each individual's story moulded into a clinical diagnosis. We learnt that Sustainable Development Goals and the medical humanities are not two separate projects, but two vocabularies for understanding suffering in context.
References
1. Garwicz M. Empathy and compassion – so important yet so complex 2022 [Available from: https://portal.research.lu.se/en/projects/empathy-and-compassion-so-important-yet-so-complex-asg-pufendorf-/?utm_source=chatgpt.com.
2. Bernhardsson K. Narrativ medicin och medicinsk humaniora. Socialmedicinsk tidskrift. 2024.
3. Sandström I, Nyman, Lovisa, Gustafsson Lundberg, Johanna. Expanding the Discourse on Sustainability: Existential Sustainability 2024 [Available from: https://portal.research.lu.se/en/publications/expanding-the-discourse-on-sustainability-existential-sustainabil/?utm_source=chatgpt.com
4. Gudmundsson M. ‘An Embodied Journey Towards Recovery’: A Grounded Theory of Mental Health Service Users’ Experiences of a Nature-based Intervention. 2026.